Should You Buy a BMW i8 for the Price of a Toyota Camry?

When the BMW i8 debuted in 2014, it was hailed as a groundbreaking supercar, blending futuristic hybrid technology with striking design. With a starting price of $136,000, the i8 was exclusive, innovative, and unmistakably cool. Fast-forward to today, and you can find these carbon-fiber, all-wheel-drive hybrids for less than $40,000—comparable to a new Toyota Camry. But is it worth it?

A Revolutionary Vision

The BMW i8 first wowed audiences in Mission: Impossible – Ghost Protocol in 2011, capturing attention with its sleek, sci-fi look. By the time it hit production in 2014, the i8 stayed true to its concept roots, offering features like a carbon-fiber monocoque chassis, a hybrid powertrain, and cutting-edge design.

Under the hood, the i8 pairs a 1.5-liter turbocharged 3-cylinder engine (mounted in the rear) with an electric motor on the front axle. Together, these components deliver 357 horsepower and 420 lb-ft of torque through two transmissions: a 6-speed automatic for the gas engine and a 2-speed unit for the front electric motor. The result is a car that’s not just innovative but surprisingly quick—0-60 mph in 3.8 seconds and a quarter-mile in 12.4 seconds.

Despite being eclipsed by the more powerful hybrid hypercars of its time—the Porsche 918, McLaren P1, and Ferrari LaFerrari—the i8 carved out a niche as an accessible “everyman’s” supercar.

The Driving Experience

One of the biggest misconceptions about the BMW i8 is that it’s slow. While 357 horsepower may sound modest, the car’s lightweight construction (3,484 pounds) and electric torque fill make it feel much faster than the numbers suggest. In Sport mode, with launch control engaged, the i8 delivers a thrilling surge of power that rivals many modern performance cars.

The i8’s handling strikes a balance between sporty and comfortable. Its narrow tires and soft suspension might limit its track performance, but on real-world roads, the car shines. It’s nimble, composed, and surprisingly compliant on long drives.

Design That Defies Time

The BMW i8 remains one of the most visually arresting cars on the road. Its low front end, distinctive kidney grilles, and dramatic “flying buttresses” make it look as if it belongs in the future. This design has aged gracefully, often mistaken for a brand-new model even a decade later.

Inside, the i8 offers a similarly futuristic vibe. The dual-cockpit layout, blue accents, and unique steering wheel create a cabin that feels special. While some elements, like the small infotainment screen, betray the car’s age, the overall design remains a standout in 2025.

Reliability: Myths and Realities

One reason for the i8’s steep depreciation is its perceived complexity. With a hybrid powertrain, multiple transmissions, and advanced electronics, the i8 might seem like a maintenance nightmare. However, owners and mechanics report that the car is more reliable than expected.

High-voltage battery: The i8’s battery has proven durable, with minimal degradation even after years of use. Replacements are available for around $8,000—far less than the six-figure costs associated with hypercar batteries.

Engine and drivetrain: The 1.5-liter turbocharged engine is shared with the Mini Cooper and has a reputation for reliability. Routine maintenance, such as oil changes and spark plugs, is straightforward.

Common issues: Some i8s have experienced air conditioning compressor failures, fuel pressure sensor malfunctions, and worn door struts. While these repairs can be costly, they’re not as widespread as online forums might suggest.

Practical Considerations

As stunning as the i8 is, it’s not without compromises:

Ingress and egress: Getting in and out of the car is a challenge, thanks to its high sills and butterfly doors. For taller or older drivers, it may feel more like a yoga session than a smooth entry.

Storage space: The trunk is tiny, and there’s no front trunk due to the placement of the electric motor. Long trips might require creative packing—or skipping altogether.

Rear seats: While technically a 2+2, the rear seats are more decorative than functional, suitable only for small bags or very small passengers.

Should You Buy One?

If you’re looking for a car that turns heads, delivers an exhilarating driving experience, and costs less than a fully loaded Camry, the BMW i8 is hard to beat. It offers the rare combination of supercar styling, hybrid efficiency (up to 40 MPG), and a surprisingly livable driving experience.

Depreciation has made the i8 an accessible entry point into the world of exotic cars, and its robust reliability record makes it less of a gamble than many might assume. While it’s not for everyone, those who embrace its quirks will find a car that feels just as special today as it did when it launched.

For more automotive reviews and news, visit TFLcar’s website, and you can follow on Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram. To watch the full video about the BMW i8, head over to the TFL YouTube channel.